Not a Cookie-Cutter Cookie Company

Personalized Cookies

19+ 5-star reviews
The Perfect Gift Personalized cookies show that you put thought into choosing a unique present, making it a meaningful gesture that will be cherished.
Clean Ingredients We only use five high-quality ingredients. No seed oils, no natural flavors. A lot less calories and a lot less sugar than a store-bought cookie.
Eco-Friendly Packaging From the shipping box to the wax and the twine we source, we strive to use compostable, biodegradable, and recycled materials across the board.
  • The Perfect Gift Personalized cookies show that you put thought into choosing a unique present, making it a meaningful gesture that will be cherished.
  • Clean Ingredients We only use five high-quality ingredients. No seed oils, no natural flavors. A lot less calories and a lot less sugar than a store-bought cookie.
  • Eco-Friendly Packaging From the shipping box to the wax and the twine we source, we strive to use compostable, biodegradable, and recycled materials across the board.

Don't take our word for it

Testimonials

  • 5

    ‚ÄúI really love these cookies! They taste so simple but flavorful, with the texture of these butter biscuits I used to get at bakeries in India. I plan to cookie message myself if I have to, but if my friends and family are listening, please send me your holiday greetings via cookie. I will re-experience the gratitude for days (or at least hours)!‚ÄĚ

    Athmeya, NY

  • 5

    ‚ÄúI am so grateful you were able to ship the cookies all the way to Alaska! They were delicious; we couldn't stop at just one! And, the personalized note was so cool. Thank you again!‚ÄĚ

    Anna, AK

  • 5

    ‚ÄúWhat a sweet surprise! Our cookies arrived intact and fresh with the exact wording I wanted. I wanted to surprise my husband for his birthday, so I suggested a few different short phrases -- some about his birthday, some quotes from his favorite shows and movies. He was delighted! And the cookies were super yummy too.‚ÄĚ

    Natalie, MA

  • 5

    ‚ÄúI really liked them they were soft, not overly sweet, and almost wholesome‚ÄĚ

    Nathan, NY

  • 5

    ‚ÄúJust received my order today. They were perfect. Packaging was perfect! The cookies were perfect!‚ÄĚ

    Carol, NY

  • 5

    ‚ÄúFinally ate them last night, delicious! Strangely addictive. Very subtle flavor and texture at first..and then a nice buttery aftertaste and almost chewyness that brought me back wanting more!‚ÄĚ

    Jonathan, CA

  • 5

    ‚ÄúThe cookies are delicious, and the packaging was SO cute, I loved it! I didn't realize that the packaging would be so perfect for gifts.‚ÄĚ

    Kate, MA

  • 5

    ‚ÄúGood job! It's a perfect dunking cookie. None were cracked and we love the packaging - easy to get out of the box and they're protected and no fears of them getting stale. The box is just right size for the order. Fits a cup of tea perfectly. Also the lemon flavor is right on, smooth not too much lemon paired with the butter taste. Really solid cookies. We really like them. Perfect.‚ÄĚ

    Rich and Carol, NY

  • 5

    ‚ÄúYou really have a great product on your hands. I do a lot of baking so I am picky about my sweets but you nailed it. I really do love the packaging it's simple but there's so much attention to detail all at the same time. I would definitely order these and send as gifts. I think the pricing is on point too especially for such a quality product. Thank you again!‚ÄĚ

    Lisa, PA